The Delhi High Court on Wednesday sought replies from the Law Ministry, Finance Ministry, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) in response to a petition seeking regulation of payment companies like Google Pay, Amazon Pay and PhonePe, among others. LiveLaw was the first to report the development.
The petition, filed by applied economist Reshmi P Bhaskaran, states that in the absence of dedicated regulations, non-licensed technology companies and e-commerce players, “TechFins”, have entered the financial domain through partnerships with existing entities and are competing with regulated financial institutions without having to comply with the same requirements. “That such operation of technology companies in the finance sector poses potential risk to financial security, potential breach of systematic citizen’s data, customers including businesses and customers and is thereby requested to be regulated by the petitioner,” it says.
The petition alleges that TechFin firms operate in an unregulated environment as third-party apps and deliberately identify loopholes in the existing regulatory regime. “That by working as third party providers or as a channel between the financial entities and customers, they are able to take advantage of legal and regulatory loopholes which allows these ‘TechFins’ to offer financial services in their own names without attracting the need for financial/banking license, authorization of compliance with any major regulations.” The petitioner said that the regulatory framework allows non-regulated TechFins to operate in the Unified Payment Interface (UPI) ecosystem as well.
“It is submitted that in terms of regulations, these ‘TechFins’ (for example Google or Amazon) operating under the UPI payment systems as TPAP [third-party apps] are ‘shallow’ entities as it is the Payment Service Providers which bears the brunt, liability and risk mitigation requirements of all regulators and also takes up all the liability of these ‘TechFins’ or Third Party App Providers in the UPI ecosystem,” it says. It said that added together, Google Pay, PhonePe and Amazon Pay control 85% market share in UPI payments.
Further, the petition said that main purpose of TechFins operating payments is to collect more customer data. “That at this juncture it is pertinent to point out that the current financial regulations do not cover the shortcomings that occur from the incorrect use of financial data by TechFin Companies, as the data delivery to financial institutions is not a regulated activity in our country.”
- Competition Commission orders investigation in Google’s App Store and GPay
- RBI clarifies that Google Pay is not a payments system operator, not in violation of Payments & Settlements Act: Report
- CCI dismisses petition alleging WhatsApp abused dominance to enter UPI market
- Supreme Court issues notice in plea filed by CPI MP seeking regulations to protect UPI data
- NPCI publishes UPI market share data, yet to consult players on 30% cap