"If all intermediaries proactively monitor content, there will be mass-scale private surveillance, given the entire Intermediary Rules amendment," said Sarvjeet Singh from the Centre for Communications Governance, NLU Delhi. "This also totally violates Puttaswamy judgement," he added. "Mandating the use of automated tools to carry out proactive monitoring of content can result in a prior-restraint regime," said Prasanna S., an advocate. He was speaking at MediaNama’s discussion on Intermediary Liability in Delhi on October 23, conducted in partnership with CCG-NLU Delhi, with support from Google, Facebook, and the Friedrich Naumann Foundation. Proactive takedowns may blur the line between a passive and an active intermediary, and goes against the very nature of what an intermediary is, according to Tanya Sadana of Ikigai Law. A intermediary is merely a passive transmitter of information and has no active knowledge; proactive monitoring is "antithetical to its very being". “You cannot have Safe Harbour provision based on [platforms] having no knowledge, and then impose a liability of removing the Safe Harbour provision because you are not proactively monitoring content. You're damned if you do, and damned if you don't.” — Tanya Sadana, Ikigai Law [caption id="attachment_206784" align="aligncenter" width="1200"] Sarvjeet Singh, CCG @ NLU Delhi[/caption] Effectiveness of AI in tackling problematic content The draft Intermediary Rules mandate proactive monitoring and removal of unlawful content, using automated tools or appropriate mechanisms. But the effectiveness of AI — which is an automated tool — depends on the quantity and quality of data that is fed into the algorithm. This can be a…
- “Foreign state actor” may be responsible for the ransomware attack on AIIMS-Delhi: Report December 3, 2022
- Agenda: Reworking The Data Protection Bill, Delhi, 8th Dec #Ad December 3, 2022
- Why has the deadline to comply with UPI market share cap been extended by the NPCI? December 3, 2022
- India’s IT Minister on DPDP Bill: Law should be kept ‘simple’, subordinate rules won’t exceed Act December 3, 2022
- MIB approves ninth self regulatory body, PADMA, under the IT Rules, 2021 December 3, 2022
MediaNama’s mission is to help build a digital ecosystem which is open, fair, global and competitive.
The Structure and Style of a Dogma Community: Conspiracy theories and organized Twitter engagement on Sushant Singh Rajput
Studying the 'community' supporting the late Sushant Singh Rajput (SSR) shows how Twitter was gamed through organized engagement
Do we have an enabling system for the National Data Governance Framework Policy (NDGFP) aiming to create a repository of non-personal data?
A viewpoint on why the regulation of cryptocurrencies and crypto exchnages under 2019's E-Commerce Rules puts it in a 'grey area'
India's IT Rules mandate a GAC to address user 'grievances' , but is re-instatement of content removed by a platform a power it should...
Why ‘group privacy’ should be recognised, and how ‘non-personal’ data becomes a regulatory blindspot
There is a need for reconceptualizing personal, non-personal data and the concept of privacy itself for regulators to effectively protect data
Please subscribe to MediaNama. Don't share prints and PDFs.
You May Also Like
Google has released a Google Travel Trends Report which states that branded budget hotel search queries grew 179% year over year (YOY) in India, in...
135 job openings in over 60 companies are listed at our free Digital and Mobile Job Board: If you’re looking for a job, or...
Twitter takes down tweets from MP, MLA, editor criticising handling of pandemic upon government request
By Aroon Deep and Aditya Chunduru You’re reading it here first: Twitter has complied with government requests to censor 52 tweets that mostly criticised...