Sampad Swain: What Do Local Businesses Really Want?


This post has been part of my draft for almost 8 months now. For obvious reasons, I’ve not posted it. But now since I’m out of DealsAndYou.com, I thought of posting my point of view without any guilt trip.

So to start off, the daily deals industry actually started around end of 2009, and a friend and I gave it an early shot, with all guns blazing. However, the industry quickly shaped up like typical FMCG industries where money is the biggest ammunition to stay afloat, while revenue is out of volume sales.

Now, that’s not what a typical fledging startup thinks early on or rather wants also, but that’s the nature of quickgrowing business models.We got acquired & our fledgling startup got rebranded as DealsAndYou. That’s that.

The sales pitch to the local businesses was simple – helping them in offsetting the un-utilized inventory over a period of time by giving deep discounts to walk-in customers. That worked – definitely it did. That’s why we saw many daily deal companies raising multi-dollar funding to the tune of around $50 Mn in India aggregately in the last 2 years alone for geographic expansion, increasing sales footprint, operations cost etc, with definite revenue base (I’m not getting into the debate of Gross Merchandise Value vs revenue vs margins vs net profit etc).

But the question is, what problem did daily deal companies solve? After spending almost 2 years in the industry, I would say that they swayed away from the problem statement, wherein they were supposed to help local businesses in offsetting under-utilized inventory problem.

This problem came up another set of problems. Since daily deal companies were more like a destination portal for consumers to pick and choose which deal to buy; so customers often bought those deals which had less riders, were more easy on their wallet (i.e. more discounts), and could be redeemed almost anytime based on their convenience etc. Now if we focus on solving the customers purchase decision, then the local businesses issue takes a back seat, which is why there have been rants globally that daily deal companies don’t have long term sustenance, or that local businesses would slowly move away from them, since its a deal-breaker over a longer period of time.

Now, lets understand what exactly local businesses really want which in my opinion daily deal companies can’t really solve with the present set of business metrics which is more biased towards consumer convenience (don’t get me wrong here – serving consumers & providing convenience isn’t wrong. Its just the way business models work in daily deals businesses).

So for local businesses, daily deal models are slowly shifting from “need to have (N2H)” to “good to have (G2H)“.

So to put it in black & white, local businesses actually want this:

  • Attract customers at lesser discounts (of course much less than what daily deal companies give, of over 50%)
  • Customers walk-ins almost 24X7 and not necessarily during those hours when customers want to come, which is the late evenings & weekends because businesses are almost running full during those times.
  • Lesser logistical nightmare like contracts, signups, deal structuring etc i.e. something more flexible which takes care of unorganized nature of the local businesses.
  • Creating a pool of loyal customers & not being type-cast as discounted place.
  • Something which helps the local business shift demand to those times when they are actually dull or running slow. That way, businesses can actually offset their un-utilized inventory problem.

Now such flexible, easy & intelligent way of helping local businesses is difficult for daily deal businesses to solve because of the business model paradigm (mentioned above) – but it is definitely is a huge opportunity at a global scale since the problem of unused inventory or lean hours problem is faced by almost all business.

Sampad Swain is a serial entrepreneur, and is currently working on a stealth startup. He had co-founded DealsAndYou, prior to which he founded Wanamo which was acquired. More here - on Twitter and on LinkedIn.

Crossposted from SampadSwain.com with permission.

Popularity: 1% [?]

  • http://twitter.com/sobelix Saurabh Sengupta

    From the horse’s mouth. Good article! There’s another phenomena I noticed – deal companies spreading too thin – most companies were focusing on Spas and Restaurants. I have a hunch that it may have worked well in the case of (say) the hospitality / tourism industry during off-season. I have noticed this change in snapdeal lately where they are choosing their battles and shifting focus to more off-beat verticals (other than spas and restaurants). Lets see how it works.

  • Raxit Sheth

    Really much insight !

  • http://www.arjunram.com arjunram

    Good post Sampad. Couldn’t agree more on the fundamental requirements of the local business. However I always thought in the context of India and local businesses – the deals was and is an interesting play heres why. Deals was probably the first exposure to the internet for most local businesses. Just Dial was still an offline model thru telephones/mobile.
    It would be interesting to see how business feel about them today. Loyalty and discounts have been tried before by folks like Metromela, Open2save but may be their timing was off. The issue has always been how do you close the loop with the consumer. That in essence is the holy grail of local merchants IMHO.

    Any business that figures out how to close the loop is bound to make a lot more money than simple lead generation. My 2cents.

    -Arjun

  • Anonymous

    good stuff Sam vouch for this! The daily deal portals haven’t really solved the real problem for a small service provider. Just like the traditional job portals haven’t solved the recruitment problem. Lot of innovations possible around this large untapped problem :-)

  • http://www.mobikwik.com/ Bipin Preet Singh

    Good one, Sampad.

  • Ankit

    Well said Sampat as Abhishek has said it is a large untapped opportunity..I think someone has to go the AOL way and launch local sites like “Patch”, having small community based websites dedicated to each city..This would help local businesses and penetrate a largely untapped market of  local advertising…

  • Amit

    guess the author here wrongly interpreting his views with notion of assumptions when started. He is addressing a supplier push forward business model and fails to understand the consumer insights from the market. This is B2C where the needs must be validated from the consumers point of view. Guess Sampad is addressing the problems when there is a horizontal integration of the suppliers and the portal owner in the value chain. Let me take this opportunity to give you an example of dutch website ibood.nl which is targeting the daily deals per a single product.   This is innovation !! 

  • Amit

    forgot to mention that simplicity is lacking in today’s deal portals. Discount must be very substantial and it must catch the heart of a consumer. and it can be done very well when you only showcase a single product. too many disocunts and too many products will thwart the consumer …i have set groupon.nl, sweetdeals.nl and ibood.nl in my browser and honestly when I start my day its ibood’s simple offering that makes me remember the deal of the day. and there are many mores who also share my views. rather than addressing the inventory problems if the deal portals succeed in addressing what consumer is looking and take the pattern and offer just that then it sells …for example products related to festivals, seasons,…if you check every consumer has a seasonal pattern to buy electronic goods, cloths for their kids, toys for their kids..so reverse engineer this and not push the supplier based model to showcase the deals based on minimizing inventories. 

  • nasir khan

    it was an intresting post..i liked it.. from baap.me

  • nasir khan

    it was an intresting post..i liked it.. from baap.me

  • http://twitter.com/rashmiranjan rashmiranjan

    Agree with most of the points. Hopefully Shoppers On solves some of these needs/wants if not all.

  • http://twitter.com/rashmiranjan rashmiranjan

    Agree with most of the points. Hopefully Shoppers On solves some of these needs/wants if not all.