BCCL Cuts Salaries; Dhariwal Writes To Employees About The Road To Unprofitability


Update: Added increment rollback formula below. 

Ravi Dhariwal, CEO of The Times of India Group wrote to employees in the afternoon today, about how the company has fared in the last few months, and suggested the following measures:

a) There will be no salary revision in August this year
b) There will be no TVP pay out in August this year
c) There will be  a  roll back of increment for all employees starting March 1, 09.  This will be graded, i.e. employees who got a smaller increase will get a lower reduction and the employees who got a higher increase will have a higher reduction of their  increment.

Update: The salary rollback formula is as follows

rollback

The complete text of his email below

ContentSutra reported on this development first, and we also received the letter that Dhariwal sent out, from independent sources. Earlier, last month, Exchange4Media had reported on an emaiil that Dhariwal sent out to directors of the company. We had reported 10% layoffs at the group earlier last year, though now it appears things are worse. 
BCCL isn’t the only Media company cutting back – NDTV too has reportedly cut salaries.
 
The Road To Unprofitability

In the letter, Dhariwal suggests that tougher times will follow, but at some point in time last year, BCCL had become a billion dollar company. The first “bump in the road” came when the company began paying 60-70% more for newsprint, which brought profitability down to half. To counter this, they increased the cover price marginally, rationalized pages and cut down on costs, which made the company profitable during August, September and October. Ironically, October was the best month in the history of BCCL, in terms of revenues, according to the letter.

Then, advertising declined by almost a quarter – and with advertising accounting for over 90% of the groups revenues – the company has not been able to restore profitability. They had to borrow significantly to continue capacity expansion.

Aside of this letter, we’re told by our sources that the layoffs continue, week on week, at both Indiatimes and Times Business Solutions. MediaNama had reported on the layoffs at BCCL earlier last year, and todays letter from Dhariwal puts things into perspective about why the group also decided to rationalize spends on the Internet businesses.

Dear Colleagues,

Over the last five years we have had a dream run  as a company. In July 2008,  we grew to be a billion dollar company, growing at 20% per annum, nicely profitable, growing shares in almost all geographies, expanding our editions into newer territories and winning important competitive battles. Why do I  call it a dream run? Because we met success everywhere, including  against competitive attacks in large markets. This encouraged us to think of expanding even more rapidly. We made plans to double our capacity, launch many more new editions, take Mirror to other cities and continue to grow our business at the same pace.  Not only our business, we all grew both professionally and personally in the last 5 years.

Starting May-June last year, the first road bump in the form of newsprint prices hit us.  We started paying between 60-70% more for newsprint than we had been paying previously.  This depleted our profitability to less than half of what we had  enjoyed previously.  We saw some of it coming, and took necessary steps to mitigate it as much as possible.  Small cover price increase, rationalization of pages, strictly incurring only necessary costs were our focus then.  By doing these, we were able to keep ourselves profitable though at a reduced level during the first three months of  August, September and October.   Actually October was our best month in the history of BCCL in terms of revenue, though our profits were at half the level of what we had originally expected. All because of the higher newsprint costs.  At that stage, we thought we will be able to cut more costs and restore the company to its original financial health.  Profit is like oxygen – if we don’t have it, the company and its employees eventually suffocate. We needed to ensure a level of profitability which provided enough cash for us invest in future growth.  Till October we were confident that we would be able to do so.

The last four months have turned out to be very challenging.  Instead of growing like in the previous three months, we saw advertising decline by almost a quarter, and, because  over 90% of our revenue comes from advertising revenue, this has been huge barrier for us. I am happy that we took precautionary steps to reduce the costs, but, unhappy that these have not been enough to restore our profitability.  I am happy that we have not eroded our competitive position, in fact we have become even better, but unhappy that we have had to borrow money significantly to continue our capacity expansion.  I am happy that all our colleagues have risen to the challenge, but unhappy that the challenge seems to be lasting longer than a few months.  Frankly, I have not seen anything like this in my working life.

In times like these,  we all are asked to make personal adjustments and sacrifices  for a  greater cause; to nurse the company back to the pink of health it once was.  I am sure all of us  are working harder, and, hopefully smarter to overcome the challenges that we face.  Today, every advertisement is a battle won and every rupee earned is hard fought.  Advertisers and Agencies have simply cut their planned promotional budgets, a mistake in my opinion as advertising is  the best way to ensure top of line growth, but, I guess they are dealing with their own issues and demons.  We are trying innovative approaches including integrated solutions of all the media that BCCL owns, to provide an effective solution to our advertisers. But, each deal seems to  require much more persuasion  and does not bring as much revenue as it used to.  I am confident that with our continuing innovations towards advertising sales, we would  gain  competitive position, and when recovery does happen, and it inevitably will, we will be best placed to ride it.

In the meantime I am asking each one of you to do even more.  As a token of our oneness with the company, I am suggesting the following steps:

a)      There will be no salary revision in August this year
b)      There will be no TVP pay out in August this year
c)      There will be  a  roll back of increment for all employees starting March 1, 09.  This will be graded, i.e. employees who got a smaller increase will get a lower reduction and the employees who got a higher increase will have a higher reduction of their  increment. This is explained in the attached table.

I know this will affect everyone, but it will help  in nursing the  company back to health, and that will allow us, to once again, continue our growth both professionally and personally.  Our future in the company depends on how quickly and effectively we put it back on the path of profitability.  I am sure I can count on all your support towards this goal. What we do now, in the next few months, will greatly determine how we come out of this challenge. And resume our company’s and our own professional and personal progress. About this I am sure.

Warm regards, friends.

Ravi

Popularity: 3% [?]

  • anon

    would have loved to see the attached table on what the salary reduction percentages are like. Anyway if doing this means lesser layoffs, its always a welcome step

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/NikhilPahwa Nikhil Pahwa

    hmm…true. Have asked for the attachment. will update

  • sane man

    Nothing better than de-risking will help the group in future. Although easier said than done. Mr.Dhariwal should build/increase other engines of revenue by leveraging its core strenghts. Subscription (Broadcasting, VAS, Internet), Tickets ( Movies ) . Perhpas what has hit hard also is their private treaties deal as valuation of most deals post 07 must have turned below par.

  • akanksha

    i think the salary cut must be performance oriented. if all employees are equally measured then in that case you are lowering the motivation of people who were trying their level best and the ones who were not doing anything are motivated not to work because all are just the same.

  • whosane

    whats the story with other internet groups? heard things are pretty bad at consim too…over 300 layoffs etc..?

  • $…..ajooba….$

    wow,,,, what a step…please do not do more ..otherwise future of all employee will move toward darkness

  • employee

    even ndtv is believed to be cutting salaries in a similar fashion…how are the other groups doing? interestingly the media goes to town with news of cost cutting measures across industry sectors but when it comes to their own house no news is available on that

  • Akhil

    what about HT ?

  • Gagan

    Is it true that Times Group and HT media are undergoing some kind of an agreement on media sales. HT media sales shall be also done by Times Group. Kindly confirm whether this is true or just a rumor?

  • laila

    are these salary cuts based on the increments given last year? Please confirm

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Leonard16 Leonard16

    yeah on the last incremnt

  • Manmeet

    Bull#%@* crap! BCCL is one of the most profitable media groups in the country. The company seems to be guided only by profit and profit alone. Would Mr Dhariwal care to say what percentage of the total expenditure is incurred on manpower. The group spends a mere 10 per cent of its total expenditure on employees. What a shame! Seems like Mr Dhariwal wants to bring this down to zero (or near zero). No wonder they treat their editorial staff like dirt.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/FlowingInk FlowingInk

    I think all companies should focus on cutting the frills & not the basics. Paycuts are acceptable if they are compensating that for not doing layoffs.
    Has or is anyone giving it a thought what all these 1000s & 1000s of layoffs will do to the crime scene in the city & country?? More effectively for people who cant handle the fact that they dont have financial freedom anymore & how they are going to overcome their regular lifestyle which is full of expense, credit cards, debts & more…
    Let there be paycuts & that too above the levels of certain grades where there are more frills attached. Cut off – Perks, Incentives, Usage of unnecessary leisure & status symbol items & expenditure.
    Layoffs is like running away from a problem. By doing that we may just be feuling the formation & foundation of a Grim Society full of cheat, vengence & crime. And it'll be too late to realise what we have done to the Society by large for bringing back "A" Company back to the Pink of Health!!!!!!

  • Sammy

    Its time to get into mergers & getting the money flow in between companies. Digital media is supposed to have suffered the maximum as its major revenue source is advertising. Focus should soon be diverted to other sources.

  • Bazoomba

    What about the employees who were Hired last year only. Will they also face a salary Cut?

  • Rocky

    last four months were bad where is the profitibility of last 5 yrs gone………. when the company was doing well (as per Mr dhaliwal) ?????????????? Doesnt Mr Jain has that much money left to sustain the salaries of their staff ???? Am I wrong?

  • Gagan

    hey rocky, have you forgotten the Absolute radio deal of Rs 550 crores :-)

  • Vins

    are uska kya hoga jise apraisal mila hi nai, m waiting for my apraisal from last 1.5 yr, if still not got apraisal then it ll not b fare at all.

    performing from last 1.5 yr. and now no apraisal scene, it sucks. :(

  • zom

    na na, mr. jain will not going to share that money with staff, but money can b spent on celebrities, for e.g. (Holi party)

  • zxxx

    The better way to fight with financial crisis in BCCL please remove subsidies on food(lunch n Breakfast).i think it will help you in lesser layoffs n organizational health.